Traditional Flats
Tried and true, our flat cookie selection is the perfect combination of recognizable flavors and notable palette pleasers.
Chocolate Chip
Our authentic family recipe baked with rich chocolate morsels.
Peanut Butter
A peanut butter cookie topped with sugar, and pressed with a traditional criss-cross.
Cinnamon Oatmeal
A cinnamon cookie dough baked with oats and cinnamon chips.
Chocolate Sugar
A chocolate cookie dough rolled in coarse sugar.
White Chocolate Almond
An almond flavored cookie dough garnished with slivered almonds, and drizzled with white chocolate.
Red Devils
A Red Devil's food flavored cookie with white chocolate morsels baked in.
Lemon
A lemon zest flavored cookie with white chocolate morsels baked in.
M&M
Our authentic family recipe baked with candy coated chocolate morsels.
Snickerdoodle
A sweet cookie dough kissed with cinnamon and sugar.
Carrot Cake
A spiced cookie baked with shredded carrots, dark raisins and chopped walnuts, drizzled with glaze
Dark Chocolate Coconut
A light coconut flavored cookie baked with coconut flakes and dark chocolate chips.
Cranberry Macadamia Nut
A sweet butter cookie with cranberries, white chocolate morsels and macadamia nuts baked in.
Orange
An orange zest flavored cookie with white chocolate morsels baked in.
Ginger
A traditional ginger cookie baked with molasses.
Thumbprints
Scooped, rolled and iced, this cookie is the foundation of our bakery. The recipe dates back to Hillary & Hailey's, Aunt Judy’s handwritten recipe card and has evolved from a traditional walnut covered cookie to the variety of flavors we now offer.
Walnut
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in crushed walnuts, topped with seasonally colored vanilla buttercream
Chocolate Sprinkle
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in chocolate sprinkles, topped with chocolate buttercream.
Peanut Butter Fudge
A peanut butter thumbprint cookie rolled in sugar, topped with chocolate buttercream.
Coconut Jelly
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in coconut, topped with raspberry filling.
Banana Nut
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in crushed walnuts, topped with banana buttercream.
Triple Chocolate
Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in chocolate sprinkles, topped with chocolate buttercream.
Chocolate Celebration
Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in seasonal colored sprinkles, and topped with chocolate buttercream.
Mint Chocolate
This is Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in chocolate sprinkles, topped with mint buttercream.
M&M
Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in M&M candies, topped with chocolate buttercream.
Chocolate Coconut
Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in coconut, topped with vanilla buttercream.
Strawberry Crunch
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in strawberry crumb, topped with strawberry whip.
Orange Crunch
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in orange crumb, topped with orange buttercream.
Hawaiian
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in coconut, topped with pineapple whip.
Pumpkin
A pumpkin spice flavored thumbprint cookie rolled in cinnamon and sugar, topped with pumpkin spice buttercream.
Sugar Plum
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in sugar, topped with plum buttercream & shimmer.
Celebration
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in seasonal colored sprinkles, topped with vanilla buttercream.
Peanut Butter
A peanut butter thumbprint cookie rolled in sugar, topped with peanut butter chocolate.
Raspberry Almond
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in slivered almonds, topped with raspberry buttercream.
Maple Pecan
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in crushed pecans, topped with maple buttercream.
Cookies and Cream
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in crushed Oreos, topped with cookies & cream buttercream.
Chocolate Walnut
Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in crushed walnuts, topped with chocolate buttercream.
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in chocolate sprinkles, topped with strawberry whip.
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in chocolate sprinkles, topped with peanut butter buttercream.
Cookies & Scream
Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in Halloween sprinkles, topped with halloween cookies and cream buttercream.
German Chocolate
Our signature chocolate thumbprint cookie rolled in coconut & pecans, topped with traditional German chocolate frosting.
Blueberry Crunch
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in blueberry crumb, topped with blueberry whip.
Lemon Crunch
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in lemon crumb, topped with lemon buttercream.
Apple Cinnamon
A traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in cinnamon and sugar crumb, topped with apple cinnamon buttercream.
Grinch
A Grinch green traditional thumbprint cookie rolled in green cookie crumb, topped with matching buttercream, garnished with a red sugar heart.
Gingerbread
A ginger & molasses flavored thumbprint cookie rolled in sugar, topped with cinnamon buttercream.
Specialty
Intricate and meticulous, these cookies are sandwiched, filled, powdered or all of the above.
Horns
A traditional sweet, buttery dough filled with walnuts, apricot, or raspberry, rolled in sugar.
Crinkles
A soft chocolate cookie rolled in powdered sugar baked into a crackled exterior.
Pecan Tassies
A traditional cookie crust filled with caramelized pecans.
Linzers
A buttery almond flavored shortbread cookie, filled with raspberry or apricot, dusted with powdered sugar.
Cream Wafers
A buttery and flaky sandwich cookie filled with vanilla buttercream.
Buttercream Sprinkles
A confetti sugar cookie dough topped with vanilla buttercream & seasonal colored sprinkles.
